A Fresh Perspective on Campaign Finance Reform (5 Responses)

These pieces from Wendy Kaminer shed a fresh perspective on the Citizens United Case — a bit argumentative, but definitely worth reading.

The Foolishness of Campaign Finance Reformers

What should we do now that campaign finance has failed?

The New York Times’ disingenuous campaign against Citizens United

The truth about Citizens United and outside campaign cash

The call for overturning Citizens United does appear to be misguided in my view, as I have previously suggested in this thread.

The perils of a constitutional amendment that determines that corporations have none of the protections afforded individuals by the Bill of Rights include greater ability of government to limit the activities of corporations like Planned Parenthood — consider the foundation of the rulings made in this case Planned Parenthood of Missouri v. Danforth which was decided after Roe v. Wade, and spoke to the rights of physicians to perform abortions. The court did not find it necessary to address the constitutionaliy of a restriction on activities of Planned Parenthood, because it struck down Missouri’s laws as invalid restrictions on the activities of individuals. But in post-amendment world in which corporations have no constitutional rights, nothing would stop a state from prohibiting Planned Parenthood from operating a facility to perform abortions (while allowing physicians the right to practice as individuals).

Make a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

(required)

You can make the comment area bigger by pulling the arrow. If you are techie, you can use basic HTML tags and attributes to format your comment.

    {"widget_type":"comment_query","include_string":10865,"exclude_string":"","page":0,"query_type":""}
    Powered by open source software: LAMP, WordPress, Plugins include: Akismet, TablePress, Yet Another Related Posts Plugin. Graphic Design by Jane Winsor. Development of Responsive Tabs Theme by Will Brownsberger. Hosted by Inmotion Hosting. Hosting paid for by the Brownsberger Commitee.

    Welcome!

    WillBrownsberger.com is a conversation:

    • You can comment on any post this site.
    • You can post your own new subjects on this site.
    • You do not need a password.
    • I absolutely depend on your feedback.

    You can subscribe at this link for occasional email news from this site

    Will Brownsberger
    State Senator
    2d Suffolk and Middlesex District